Better Disagreements

This post from Paul Graham,  Y Combinator founder, is fantastic.  I came across it two years ago and it’s stuck with me every since.  Imagine how better things would be if people learned to disagree better.

The thesis is that, online, there’s bound to be more disagreement than agreement because there’s not much to add when you agree with someone.  So, if that’s the case, we better start to learn to have better disagreements.

Enter the Disagreement Hierarchy (DH).

In short the disagreement hierarchy proceeds from DH0, the most base and least value adding form,  to DH6, the most powerful form of logical refutation.

DH0: Name Calling

DH1: Ad Hominem

DH2: Responding to Tone

DH3: Contradiction

DH4: Counterargument

DH5: Refutation

DH6: Refuting the Central Point

In talking with a colleague today, I realized that the disagreement hierarchy would be a wonderful think to try to code.  It could be used to generate DH scores on popular review sites and blog comments, giving readers (and writers) a sense of how well reasoned a review or comment was and how on target it was with respect to the original argument.  In the process, thoughtful reviewers could earn authority for delivering sound responses focused on issues while trolls, flamers and less thoughtful reviewers would be exposed by an objective measures.

Perhaps more importantly, such a capability could provide valuable feedback that might help well-intentioned people (not trolls, etc.) learn to compose more relevant responses, make their points more convincingly and ultimately raise the level of discourse online.

I have no doubt that building such a system with acceptable accuracy, range and nuance would be extremely difficult.  There are plenty of automated paper graders (somewhat dated overview of here).  These might be good places to build from.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Better Disagreements

  1. Pingback: Quora

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s